Tell me your views. I pretty much looked at OneCommander, Total Commander, and Directory Opus. After looking over about 15 pages, I was kind of done (Too Many Spoons), looking at more. Others started appearing, but eh for now. I think I’ll try OneCommander, and if I get frustrated, I can explore more. Others/More: Xplorer, Bitcommander, Astro, and Freecomander were the top 4 I was seeing.
I’m on windows 11. I just got prompted to tryout alternatives.
RN, the biggest things I hate about the default MS Windows Explorer are:
MS Explorer doesn’t lock folders to the top when sorting the rest of the files. It might not matter if I could lock things to the left panel, but the only things that have carets are the:
- OneDrive (eeewwww) Um NO!!! MS You’re already stealing enough of my data and life
- the top-level “This PC” (I’m not going down 4-6 directory levels )
- Libraries: Already 3 levels and a weird jerry rig
I’m sure there’s more, but yea…
The potential suggestions:
- OneCommander
- Leanterface Inc.: Milos Paripovic
- Free but $12? (Non-commercial is free) $12>30>25: Currently $25 for commercial use
- Rank: #8
- Multiple tabs
- file preview
- Basic for photos: Can’t read tags or star ratings. In June 2025, the author acknowledged the request to sort by star rating and said he would implement it in a “future” version.
- Long Path Support vs windows 250 character limit
- Batch Renaming
- Batch Image Conversion
- Uses the Windows file properties dialog to view and edit those items fully
- Uses Windows duplicate file checker to not overwrite files: Granted, Window’s is pretty decent showing date, size, and preview/thumbnail
- Some Total Commander users switched to One Commander
- CON: Grabbing a file and hovering over pinned directories in the left column doesn’t cascade open them. I guess I need to learn the Mac’s Miller Column feature, or get used to operating in two column mode (The left column isn’t cutting it, and is one thing I didn’t like about half the modules in that left column on the MS Windows Explorer. I LOVE carrots’; the cascading directories feature)
- Total Commander
- By: Ghisler Software: Christian Ghisler
- Commercial but free (30 days or???)/$42/44/50(uk-39lb)?
- Long history 20+ years
- Also available on android
- Duplicate checker: I’m leery of these lately. Merging, overwriting, deleting…
- Supports the Cloud and Archiving
- Google hasn’t been merging safely or checking which data to overwrite
- These automated ones have been only checking names not sizes
- Size alone hasn’t been showing higher quality: some of these 2meg vs 250k files have been lossy in their up-scaling
- Rank: #5
- Directory Opus
- built in sFTP (PAID add on)
- Supports tags/labels and stars of files and folders
- Supports different archive formats
- Supports archive formats like Zip, 7Zip and RAR.
- synchronization
- duplicate detection
- Batch renaming
- image viewer (“Powerful”)
- Shows full image metadata
- Uses Everything search engine
- Image Sorting ??? including tags and meta-data
- Many Total Commander and PowerDesk users switched in 2017-2020-ish
- Xplorer² (Trial-ware)
- Bit Commander
- Astro File Manager
- Enhanced Cloud features
- System cleanup tool
- Duplicate finder tool
- FreeCommander
Sources
- One Commander
- Slant.co: one-commander vs directory-opus
- Wikipedia: Comparison of file managers (Just stat’s not a features list)
- Top Business Software: Total-Commander-vs-One-Commander
- Appmus:
- SourceForge:
- Reddit:
- Windows11: what_file_manager_do_you_use/
- WindowsForum: onecommander-review-the-best-free-modern-file-manager-for-windows-in-2025.367773 (AI article: 5/2025)
- Slashdot:
- Tech Radar: Best file manager of 2026 (Updated: 12/2025)
(Refuses to discuss OneCommander) - xda-developers: 6 reasons OneCommander is my favorite free file manager for Windows, and it’s not even close
NOTE: Slashdot and Top Business Software seem to be just an AI rewording of one or the other.
linux:
on Linux Double Commander for GUI and Midnight Commander for terminal? Dolphin?
Windows search programs: (10/2025)
- AstroGrep https://astrogrep.sourceforge.net/
- Agent Ransack https://www.mythicsoft.com/agentransack/
- AnyTXT Searcher https://anytxt.net/
- Copernic Desktop Search https://copernic.com/en/
- DocFetcher https://docfetcher.sourceforge.io/
- Everything https://www.voidtools.com/ **??**
- FileSeek https://www.fileseek.ca/
- Fluent Search https://fluentsearch.net/
- grepWin-2.1.12-x64.msi https://github.com/stefankueng/grepWin/releases/tag/2.1.12
- Listary https://www.listary.com/
- Quick Search https://www.glarysoft.com/quick-search/
- Searchmonkey https://sourceforge.net/projects/searchmonkey/
- SearchMyFiles https://www.nirsoft.net/utils/search_my_files.html
- UltraSearch https://www.jam-software.com/ultrasearch
- Wise JetSearch https://www.wisecleaner.com/wise-jetsearch.html
- WizFile https://antibody-software.com/wizfile/ **??**